top of page

How to Buy Replacement Fenders Online: Ultimate Guide

replacement fenders

When your car fender falls victim to an unexpected incident, the online market is a vast resource for replacements. But where does one start in this sea of options? This comprehensive guide answers your pressing queries such as 'How much to replace a fender?' and 'How to replace a car fender?'.

We also delve into the distinction between aftermarket fenders and OEM replacement parts. So, gear up and allow us to navigate you through the market of fender replacements, ensuring a shopping experience that's as smooth as your future drive.

What to Look for in a Replacement Fenders

When searching for replacement fenders, knowing what to look for is crucial to ensure you get the best fit and quality for your vehicle. Here are a few key points to consider:

  • Fit: Above all, ensure that the replacement fender is compatible with your car's make, model, and year. A poor fit can lead to more damage and potentially unsafe driving.

  • Material: Fenders can be made from various materials, including steel, aluminum, plastic, and fiberglass. Each has its own advantages in terms of durability, weight, and cost. The right choice will depend on your vehicle and your personal preferences.

  • Finish: Depending on your needs, you may opt for a painted or unpainted fender. While painted fenders can provide a seamless look, unpainted ones offer you the freedom to customize the color and finish.

  • Quality: Look for fenders that are made with high-quality materials and craftsmanship. A lower price may be tempting, but it might not provide the same durability and fit as a higher-end product.

  • Brand Reputation: Research and look for brands with a solid reputation for quality and customer service. Check out customer reviews and ratings to get a sense of others' experiences.

  • Installation: Some fenders may require professional installation, while others can be a DIY project. Ensure you understand what the installation process will entail before making your purchase.

Identifying the Type of Fender You Need

Knowing what type of replacement fender your vehicle needs is critical to maintaining its form and function. Here's how to identify the type of car fender you need:

Vehicle Specifications

The first step is understanding your vehicle's make, model, and year. Different car models have distinct design features, which means each requires a specific type of fender. Manufacturers usually provide detailed specifications about compatible parts. Use these as your guide when shopping.

Fender Position

Fenders come in different types based on location—front driver, left side and front passenger, right side. Ensure you're clear about which fender needs replacement.

Material Preference

Consider the type of material that best suits your needs. Steel is durable and resistant, while aluminum is lightweight and rust-resistant. Plastic and fiberglass offer flexibility and are more resistant to dents and dings.

Painted or Unpainted

If you're looking for a fender that matches your car color seamlessly, a pre-painted fender could be the right choice. If you're going for a custom paint job, an unpainted fender would be more appropriate. You can also find a brand that offers custom-painted fenders.

OEM or Aftermarket

Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) fenders are designed to match the exact specifications of the vehicle's original parts, ensuring a perfect fit. On the other hand, aftermarket fenders offer a wider variety and are usually more cost-effective. They might require some adjustments for perfect fitment, though.

OEM vs. Aftermarket Fenders: The Pros and Cons

The debate between Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) and aftermarket fenders is common among car enthusiasts and casual drivers alike. Here's an objective look at the pros and cons of both:

OEM Fenders

Aftermarket Fenders


Perfect Fit: OEM fenders are designed to match the exact specifications of the vehicle's original parts, ensuring a perfect fit and easy installation.

Quality and Durability: These fenders meet the manufacturer's standards for quality and durability, providing a reliable long-term investment.

Matching Appearance: OEM fenders maintain the vehicle's aesthetic integrity, as they match the original design and color precisely.

Cost-Effective: Generally, aftermarket fenders are less expensive than OEM parts, making them an attractive option for budget-conscious buyers.

Variety: Aftermarket parts providers often offer a wide range of styles and designs, giving car owners more choices for customization.


Cost: OEM fenders typically cost more than their aftermarket counterparts due to their superior fit and quality.

Fit and Quality Variances: Aftermarket fenders may not offer the exact fit of OEM parts, potentially leading to installation challenges. The quality can also vary significantly from one brand to another.

May Alter Vehicle Appearance: If maintaining the original look of your vehicle is important to you, aftermarket parts may not be the best choice, as they might slightly alter your vehicle's appearance.

While both options have their place, when it comes to ensuring an exact fit, maintaining the original look of your vehicle, and securing long-term durability, OEM fenders usually come out on top.

They may be a more significant investment upfront, but their benefits in the long run often justify the cost. After all, peace of mind and quality comes with a price, and with OEM parts, you know exactly what you're getting.

Finding the Right Car Fender Replacement

Now that you know what to look for in a fender replacement and how to identify what you need, finding the right car fender replacement becomes a significantly less daunting task.

Let us walk you through how you can find the right one:

1. At Painted OEM Parts, we believe that the journey to the perfect fender replacement begins with your vehicle's specifics. Start by inputting your car's make and model on our home page.

2. On the car's page, select the Product Filter drop-down menu on the left side panel and choose fender. This will show you the available fender for the car make and model. Then, select the fender you need.

3. Once you're on the parts page, choose the year of your vehicle and the side of the fender you need replacing. You can also put your car's VIN or paint code to ensure your OEM fender is custom-painted to your vehicle's color. If your car has custom paint, send us a sample of your car, and we can match its color using our PPG Moonwalk painting system.

Can't find a fender for your vehicle? Don't worry. Simply send us a request, and will find it for you!

Replacement Fenders at Painted OEM Parts

Finding the right replacement fender for your vehicle can be challenging, but with Painted OEM Parts, it doesn't have to be. Equipped with the knowledge of what to look for, identifying the type of fender you need, and understanding the benefits of OEM over aftermarket parts, you're set to make the best choice for your vehicle.

At Painted OEM Parts, we provide high-quality, perfect-fit fenders that preserve the original aesthetics of your vehicle, delivering the durability and reliability you expect.

As you embark on your fender replacement journey, we're here to guide you every step of the way, ensuring an easy, stress-free shopping experience. Trust Painted OEM Parts for your replacement needs, and let us put you back on the road with confidence.


bottom of page